JUGNU DEVI OBJECTION REJECTED
The State Election Commission has rejected the objection regarding maintainability raised by the respondent, Jugnu Devi, in Case No. 50/2024, which concerns the Chief Councilor of the Shahpur Nagar Panchayat in Bhojpur district. The Commission stated that the petitioners have submitted primary and undisputed documentary evidence along with their petition. Consequently, the matter cannot be dismissed from consideration simply by labeling it as being based solely on disputed facts. Dr. Deepak Prasad, Commissioner of the Commission, issued copies of the order to all parties on November 17, 2026. This case pertains to *Krishna Kumar and Ramesh Kumar Ram vs. Jugnu Devi*. The case was heard on November 5, 2026.
JUGNU DEVI OBJECTION REJECTED
20-NOV-ENG 11
RAJIV NAYAN AGRAWAL
ARA-------------------------The State Election Commission has rejected the objection regarding maintainability raised by the respondent, Jugnu Devi, in Case No. 50/2024, which concerns the Chief Councilor of the Shahpur Nagar Panchayat in Bhojpur district. The Commission stated that the petitioners have submitted primary and undisputed documentary evidence along with their petition. Consequently, the matter cannot be dismissed from consideration simply by labeling it as being based solely on disputed facts. Dr. Deepak Prasad, Commissioner of the Commission, issued copies of the order to all parties on November 17, 2026. This case pertains to *Krishna Kumar and Ramesh Kumar Ram vs. Jugnu Devi*.
The case was heard on November 5, 2026. During the hearing, Advocate Avnish Kumar appeared for the petitioners, while Advocate Ranjeet Chaubey represented the respondent. Diwakar Das, Deputy Election Officer of Bhojpur, was present on behalf of the district administration. A written supplementary counter-affidavit was also filed by the respondent on October 26, 2026.
Counsel for the respondent (Jugnu Devi) argued before the Commission that the validity of Section 18(1)(l) of the Bihar Municipal Act, 2007, has been challenged in the Patna High Court via C.W.J.C. No. 16190/2026 (*Ranjeet Kumar Prasad vs. State of Bihar & Ors.*). According to the respondent, this petition has been admitted for hearing by a division bench of the High Court. The Commission is also a party to that case and has provided an undertaking to the court that it will not pass a final order in the matter at hand. On this basis, the respondent argued that Case No. 50/2024 is of a similar nature. Therefore, in the interest of judicial discipline and in accordance with Article 141 of the Constitution, the Commission should stay the proceedings or the issuance of any final order in this matter until the final disposal of C.W.J.C. No. 16190/2026.
Mr. S.B.K. Mangalam, counsel for the petitioners (Krishna Kumar and Ramesh Ram), informed the Commission that the respondent herself had approached the Patna High Court in C.W.J.C. No. 10276/2026, *Jugnu Devi v. State Government & Ors.* In that matter, the High Court, vide its order dated July 17, 2026, directed the State Election Commission to dispose of the case within four months. According to the petitioners, the Commission was required to pass an order in the matter by November 17, 2026. It was further argued that while C.W.J.C. No. 16190/2026—currently pending before the High Court—challenges only the validity of Section 18(1)(l), the present case also provides grounds for action under Section 18(1)(k). The petitioners also pointed out that the respondent is not a party to C.W.J.C. No. 16190/2026; therefore, she cannot automatically claim the benefit of any interim order passed in that case. The counsel requested the Commission to proceed with the hearing and reach a final disposal of the matter.
The Commission examined the arguments presented by the counsel for both parties, as well as the documents annexed to the petition. As noted in the Commission’s order, the petitioners have highlighted that the name of the respondent, Jugnu Devi, appears as 'Buyer No. 7' in the *kaiwala* (sale deed) submitted along with the affidavit. The order further notes that the respondent did not challenge the authenticity of the said *kaiwala*, nor did she deny any connection to the property in question. Furthermore, the petitioner claimed that by the time the petition was filed, only 12 meetings of the General Board and two meetings of the Empowered Standing Committee had taken place. According to the Commission, the respondent did not explicitly refute this fact in her preliminary objection. Minutes of proceedings for some of these meetings were also submitted on record by the petitioner. The Commission observed that these documents constitute sufficient primary documentary evidence to initiate the proceedings.
The Commission also rejected the respondent’s argument that the mere admission of a petition challenging the validity of Section 18(1)(l) by the High Court should necessitate a stay on all proceedings falling under that section. The Commission stated that unless the High Court has issued an explicit order staying all proceedings related to the section in question, it would not be appropriate to automatically halt hearings or refrain from passing orders in all such cases. In the Commission’s view, in the absence of a clear injunction, the relevant provision remains in effect. The Commission further held that the respondent cannot automatically claim the benefit of an interim order passed in C.W.J.C. No. 16190/2026, as she is not a party to that case.
After examining all arguments and records, the State Election Commission dismissed the objection raised by the respondent (Jugnu Devi) regarding the maintainability of the petition. The Commission has scheduled the next date for a detailed hearing of the matter for November 25, 2026, at 11:30 AM. It was also noted that the subsequent hearings and proceedings following this order on maintainability might exceed the four-month timeframe stipulated by the High Court; no objection was raised in this regard. The Commission has directed that copies of the order be provided to all parties. A copy of the order has also been forwarded to the District Election Officer (Municipalities)—who is also the District Magistrate of Bhojpur—for compliance.
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Wow
0
Sad
0
Angry
0
Comments (0)